Complete a return/exchange - Click the Initiate Return/Exchange button above and follow these steps: 

  1. Fill out the Order Number and Email fields. 
  2. Select the item(s) you’d like to return or exchange and specify the reason(s). 
  3. Select your refund preference (Exchange or Return)
  4. Print out the label provided in your return confirmation email and send back your item(s) within 30 days. International returns will not have a label generated.  

Make sure to only use our pre-paid USPS return labels so we can track your order. Separate orders should be returned separately with the coordinating return label. We are unable to refund lost returns using labels other than our own.

We want to make shopping online as trouble free as shopping in a store. For this reason, we have made our Return Policy very simple.  

You have 30 days from the day you receive your order to decide if you want to keep it, exchange it, or return it. All items are eligible for return/exchange except these few – custom, personalized or game-used items, clearance items, and items under $10 are nonrefundable and cannot be exchanged or returned. All items must be unworn, unwashed and in re-sellable condition: garments must be clean and brims of ballcaps must be unaltered and unbent (hats must be returned in a box, not an envelope).  


If you ordered an item that is the wrong size, doesn't fit right, or arrived damaged or defective, follow the above link to start your exchange process. All exchanges must be made within 30 days of receiving your product. You will not be charged for the shipping label to send back your product with an exchange. We do not offer exchanges for different items. 

Note:Items that have been discontinued since your order will need to be returned for a refund. Please note that product must be in re-sellable condition. *Additional shipping costs may apply. 


If within 30 days of delivery you are not satisfied with your product you may return it for a full refund. Shipping charges are nonrefundable. Please note that refunds may take up to 30 days from receiving the product. Product must be in re-sellable condition* and must be accompanied by original receipt. Please include the reason for your return in the return form.

For best results when returning or exchanging product, please visit our Returns Portal on BuckeyeCorner.Com. Clearance items and items under $10 are nonrefundable, and not eligible for return or exchange. Our Buckeye Corner stores are not able to take returns of online orders, but eligible items under $100 can be exchanged in-store when accompanied by your online receipt.  

*While Custom made items cannot be returned or exchanged, if the order is defective (i.e., fabric flaws, design, etc.) we will gladly exchange the order. Custom orders include, but are not limited to, name/number customizations, custom artwork, etc. If you would like to refund your item, please email 

Please note we cannot be held responsible for Buckeye Corner items purchased from other retailers or unaccompanied by sales receipt. For returns/exchanges/repairs of items that are purchased from another retailer, please consult that retailer's returns/exchanges/repair policies. 

If you have any questions, please email